Chirayuthchai TraisaengsatheanStrategic Finance for Property Development

Equity IRR from the debt structure

Enter the cash flow before debt and the loan terms to compare Project IRR with Equity IRR

Read with Real Estate Project Strategic Financial Management Handbook: A Practical Guide · Part 3
The figures entered are hypothetical examples. Every cell can be edited. Units are THB million.

1

Model settings

Choose the frequency, the start period and the required rate of return

Cash flow frequency
The first period is the starting point (period 0)
Used to label the periods in the table
% per year, used to calculate Project NPV
% per year (cost of equity), used to calculate Equity NPV
2

Cash flow before debt by period

Enter outflows and inflows as positive values, excluding loans and interest

Table for entering cash flow before debt
PeriodPeriodOutflowsInflowsNetDelete
Paste data from Excel or type a series of numbers
3

Loan terms

Facility size, interest, fees, and the drawdown and principal repayment methods

Specify the loan facility as
LTC = loan facility ÷ total net investment
–
% per year. For monthly periods, the annual rate ÷ 12 is used
% of the facility, paid by shareholders in the first drawdown period
How each period's payments are split between equity and debt
In periods with positive cash flow, interest is always paid from the project
% of cash after interest used to repay principal. The remaining balance is repaid in full in the final period
4

Project IRR vs Equity IRR

Recalculated every time a figure is changed

Equity IRR per year––
Project IRR per year–Before financing
Effect of debt (leverage)––
Equity MOIC––
  • Loan facility / LTC–
  • Peak debt balance–
  • Total interest and fees–
  • Project NPV–
  • Equity NPV–
  • Debt-free from period–
Chart of equity cash flow, cumulative project and equity balances, and debt balance
  • Shareholders put in cash
  • Shareholders receive cash
  • Outstanding debt
  • Cumulative project balance (before debt)
  • Cumulative equity balance
5

Table of cash flow, debt and equity by period

THB million · negative values shown in red

Cash flow before debt, debt schedule and equity cash flow (THB million)
PeriodProject before debtDebtEquityEvent
#PeriodNetCumulativeDrawdownInterest paidCapitalised interestPrincipal repaidClosing debt balanceNetCumulative

Row underlines: the point of maximum cumulative equity invested by shareholders (Peak Equity); the period in which cumulative equity turns positive

6

Equity IRR sensitivity

Change the debt proportion and the interest rate together

Equity IRR per year by interest rate × LTC

The gold-bordered cell is the base case. Red cells are where Equity IRR is below Project IRR (negative leverage). The LTC 0% column shows Project IRR. The last row shows Peak Equity at the base-case interest rate.

Results are calculations for learning purposes only. The figures entered are hypothetical examples, not real project data, and are not investment advice.

How to use

  1. Choose annual or monthly frequency, then enter the project discount rate and the return required by shareholders.
  2. Enter the project's cash flow before financing (outflows and inflows) starting from period 0, or paste data from Excel. You can use the same data set as in the Project IRR and NPV tool.
  3. Enter the loan terms, then compare Project IRR with Equity IRR. If Equity IRR is higher, debt is boosting the return on equity (positive leverage). If it is lower, the cost of debt exceeds the project return (negative leverage).
  4. Always read Peak Equity alongside Equity IRR. More debt can raise IRR, but it also increases risk and the interest burden. The sensitivity table shows how well the return withstands higher interest rates.

Assumptions and limitations

  • Cash flows are treated as a single lump sum at the end of each period. Loans are drawn in the same period as the payment. Interest is calculated on the opening debt balance.
  • Equity First: shareholders pay first until the total investment less the loan facility is covered, then the loan is drawn. Pro Rata: in every negative period, the loan is drawn in proportion to LTC.
  • Surplus cash after interest repays principal according to the cash sweep percentage, and the remainder is repaid in full in the final period. If project cash is not enough to pay interest, shareholders cover the shortfall.
  • You can choose to capitalise interest into principal, so the debt balance may exceed the loan facility. The loan fee is calculated on the facility and paid by shareholders in the first drawdown period.
  • For monthly periods, annual IRR = (1 + monthly IRR)12 − 1. If there are multiple IRR values, this page shows the one closest to the comparison rate and displays a warning.
  • Excludes covenants, drawdown conditions tied to construction progress, tax on interest and multi-layered debt (mezzanine).
The results are only an illustrative calculation. Actual loan terms vary by contract, so check against the project's financial model before using them for decisions.